| Name | Website | Member Since |
| 1. Steve | The Sunnydale Crypt | January 2005 |
| 2. Susan Skidmore | Spike Rulez | January 2005 |
| 3. Stuart | - | February 2005 |
| 4. Linsee | - | April 2005 |
| 5. Mary | - | April 2005 |
| 6. Jessie | Pixelated | April 2005 |
| 7. Krystal Dundorf | - | May 2005 |
| 8. Jessica | Pointexoxo | July 2005 |
| 9. Brittany | - | August 2005 |
| 10. Abra Bekker | - | August 2005 |
| 11. Buffybot | Evil Hand Issues | October 2005 |
| 12. willow_e_tara | Buffyvs | October 2005 |
| 13. Kayleigh | Buffy and the Scooby Gang | November 2005 |
| 14. Katie | - | November 2005 |
| 15. Andrea | - | February 2006 |
| 16. Lucy | - | March 2006 |
| 17. Laurie S. | - | March 2006 |
| 18. Taylor | Myspace Profile | June 2006 |
| 19. Laura | - | August 2006 |
